Best Knife For Trimming Brisket – Full Guide 2020

Brisket, arguably one of the most famous and luxurious cuts of meat for smoking. When prepared correctly and smoked well it can quickly become a masterpiece.

Growing up, like myself, you may have heard the phrase “fat means flavour”. Although i’m not denying that’s true, too much fat can cause other, less desirable effects on the meat while it smokes. When i was just learning, i often left a lot of the excess fat on as i assumed it would just melt and add a decedent savoury flavour to the brisket. Little did I know this was actually hindering a crucial step in the smoking process, and that was the formation of the dark, flavoursome, and chewy exterior known as the bark.

Since then I’ve always taken my time preparing and trimming the brisket, and have found it to be much easier when equipped with the right tool. Let’s look at the best knife for trimming brisket. 

What Is The Best Knife For Trimming Brisket?

When you’re slicing or cutting meat you are usually slicing downward, letting the knife cut right through. This is why chef knives are much heavier, and thicker as it helps with the task. Trimming brisket is a completely different story, and requires very different cutting techniques to do it efficiently and effectively. 

While trimming the brisket you are constantly slicing on different angles and because of this you require a more flexible knife. With flexibility, you also want sharpness to slice easily, and strong steel for better durability.  Because of this, the best type of knife for trimming brisket is a boning knife

The boning knife’s blade isn’t as thick as other knives such as a chef’s knife or butcher’s knife. It’s narrow, and more lightweight making it easier to make more precise cuts. For trimming brisket, you want a flexible, but strong steel to help trim and slice more easily and with a little more power.

Trimming the fat is key to developing the best bark on your brisket.

See here for our top picks on the best woods for smoking brisket.

The Best Knife For Trimming Brisket - Top Picks

Best Knife for Trimming Brisket: Mercer Culinary Genesis Boning Knife

Features:

Knife Length: 6 Inches
Blade Material: German High Carbon Forged Steel
Overall: Best Knife For Trimming Brisket

  • Quality at an affordable price
  • Stays sharp
  • Limited lifetime warranty
  • Steel could be slightly harder
  •  

What Matters The Most:

  • Safer to use for the average chef or beginners as it has a slight bolster (between the heel of the blade and the handle).
  • Comes sharp, and stays sharp for a decent amount of time for the price range.
  • The limited lifetime warranty is a great statement of quality, and it shows from it’s great reviews and mid-to-high quality make. 
  • There really isn’t anything at this quality level for this price.
  • NSF Certified.

Concerns

  • After multiple times sharpening the knife, over time it can weaken the steel and the blade becomes less even. More of an aesthetic difference, but doesn’t happen as often with higher quality steels.

Overall

This is the best knife for trimming brisket as it has all the essential qualities a boning knife should possess, but at a fraction of the price. It has great sharpness and control. For the most part it’s durable and long lasting, but if you use it heavily and it requires sharpening a lot, then you’ll find it does wear the blade quicker.

A great choice for both beginners and those more experienced looking for a quality knife without the price tag.

Best Cheap Knife For Trimming Brisket: Mercer Millennia Boning Knife

Features:

Knife Length: 6 Inches
Blade Material:Japanese High Carbon Steel
Overall: Best Cheap Knife For Trimming Brisket

  • Great grip
  • Very affordable
  • 4.8/5 with 8900+ Amazon reviews
  • Harder to keep sharp
  • Blade not as sturdy

What Matters The Most

  • Extremely affordable and a very popular choice with over 8900 reviews on amazon average 4.8/5.
  • The grip is surprisingly strong and durable.
  • The knife does come sharp, and can easily slice, trim, and de-bone, but it is harder to keep sharp.
  • NSF Certified.

Concerns

  • The knife requires sharpening more often but not too frequently. Recommended after every ten uses to keep it as sharp as it can be.
  • The steel of the blade is durable, but isn’t quite as sturdy as other options which does affect the handling of the knife while trimming brisket.

Overall

Although the knife does require sharpening more often, the Japanese steel allows for easy and quick sharpening without sacrificing durability. The handle is well designed and made, and it’s a safe and well performing knife.But, the stand out feature of this knife is certainly it’s price.

For the average chef or someone who won’t call upon this knife daily, it will definitely be a valuable addition to your kitchen tools. If you plan to use it frequently, it could be more worthwhile to spend a bit more.

Best Japanese Knife For Trimming Brisket: DALSTRONG Japanese Phantom Knife

Features:

Knife Length: 6.5 Inches
Blade Material: Japanese Tempered High Carbon Steel
Overall: Best Japanese Knife For Trimming Brisket

  • Very sharp
  • Strong and durable
  • Great grip feel and design
  • More expensive
  •  
  •  

What Matters The Most

  • Very sharp blade and the high quality Japanese steel, it stays sharp and resists wear for longer.
  • Elegant and effective design. Has great power, control, and is easily manoeuvred. 
  • Slightly longer (½ an inch), which is actually great for brisket as it makes cutting off the larger pieces of fat easier.
  • The grip, handle, and the overall weight makes it feel more effortless when trimming, slicing, or deboning. 
  • NSF Certified

Concerns

  • The “clam-shell” sheath design isn’t as user friendly, as it is more difficult to use in general. A lot of verified buyers comment that they would have much preferred a standard sheath for convenience and ease of use.

Overall

This is a top quality boning knife for trimming brisket. Elegant design, a great grip and handle, with a durable sharp blade. If you want a professional standard knife that’s built to last, then this is it. Although the price is more expensive than other medium-to-top quality boning knives, it is one of the top performers in all categories.

Best Quality Knife For Trimming Brisket: DALSTRONG Black Titanium Boning Knife

Features:

Knife Length: 6 Inches
Blade Material: German Black Titanium Coated High Carbon Steel
Overall: Best Quality Knife For Trimming Brisket

  • Life-long durability
  • Exceptional design
  • Attractive and stylish
  • Extremely sharp
  • More expensive 
  • Handle not ergonomically great

What Matters The Most

  • Extremely sharp, great for quick precise cuts. In the case of cutting brisket, it makes it effortless to trim the unnecessary fat.
  • The blade and overall knife design is stunning. Really brings character and adds to the overall experience. Five out of five style points. 
  • 100% satisfaction or money back guarantee and lifetime warranty against any defects.
  • Top quality German steel with a great balance of heftiness, flexibility, and stiffness. DALSTRONG are very confident in this, which is why they can promise such great warranties. 
  • NSF Certified

Concerns

  • The handle and grip are supposedly designed to tuck into your palm, but unless on some angles it can be more uncomfortable than a rounded grip.
  • Top quality knife, but is more expensive. If you don’t frequently use boning knives then it may be more worthwhile going for a slightly more affordable option as it will still perform 75% as well as this.

Overall

Definitely the most attractive, best quality knife for trimming brisket. Although less affordable, it’s backed with a life-long warranty against any defects. Incredibly sharp, and impressively sleek design makes it effortless when trimming brisket. It’s easily sharpened and comes with a great sheath. 

The only downside is that DALSTRONG tried too hard to create a perfectly ergonomic handle when it’s actually more comfortable using a classic grip. Overall a very visually appealing knife that performs and adds character in the kitchen.

Using a Chef Knife to Cut Brisket

If you’re not looking to purchase a specialist knife for boning, trimming, or slicing you are certainly able to use a more common knife for the job. A classic chef knife will do the trick, it will just require a little more effort and patience on your part. 

If you are going to use a chef knife to cut brisket just be a bit more careful and take your time and you will still be able to produce great results.

How to Trim Brisket

Trimming brisket is more art than science, there are several ways you can do it to the same result. The main principle is to trim as close to the protein of the meat as you can. But you don’t need to remove all the fat. Leaving roughly ⅛ of an inch will help the flavor and bark develop as the fat renders into the meat.

Watch the video below for a simple but comprehensive guide on how to trim, and prepare brisket.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Share on print

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *