Pellet smokers are a promising investment if you are wanting to start your barbecue journey or looking to develop your skills on another type of smoker. But if you haven’t had the chance to try a few different brands out it’s hard to know where to start. We’ve broken down everything you need to consider when you are weighing up the Smoke Hollow Pellet Grill Vs. Traeger Pellet Smokers.
Let’s make it simple: how does the Smoke Hollow PS2415 Pellet Grill stand up against the Traeger Grills Pro 575 Grill or Traeger Grills Ironwood 665?
Quick Comparison: Smoke Hollow Vs. Traeger
Smoke Hollow PS2415 Pellet Grill
Specification Breakdown
Dimensions: H 50” x L 25” x W 51”
Weight: 120 lbs
Temperature Range: 160°F – 485°F
Cooking Space: 440 square inches
Temperature Control: Digital, 5°F Increments
Pellet Hopper Capacity: 18 lbs
Warranty: 1 year
Traeger Pro 575 Pellet Grill
Specification Breakdown
Dimensions: H 40” x L 26” x W 53”
Weight: 124 lbs
Temperature Range: 165°F – 500°F
Cooking Space: 575 square inches
Temperature Control: WiFi, 10°F Increments
Pellet Hopper Capacity: 18 lbs
Warranty: 3 years
Traeger Ironwood 665 Pellet Grill
Specification Breakdown
Dimensions: H 46” x L 27” x W 47”
Weight: 149 lbs
Temperature Range: 160°F – 500°F
Cooking Space: 650 square inches
Temperature Control: WiFi, 10° Increments
Pellet Hopper Capacity: 20 lbs
Warranty: 3 years
Smoke Hollow Vs. Traeger: What We Are Comparing
Cooking Space
Never compromise on quality, but what use is a quality pellet grill without enough cooking space to comfortably smoke up a feast?
We’ve made sure to break down the cooking space on each model and give you an idea of what those measurements mean you can smoke without overcrowding the grill. As a rule of thumb, 300 square inches of primary cooking space is small, 450 is medium, and 600+ is large.
Construction Material & Heat Insulation
Cast iron is what we are looking for. It’s ability to hold and evenly distribute heat is game changing. Some models also have double wall insulation, which we’ve been sure to highlight as this makes a huge difference in holding temperature when smoking in colder or windier conditions.
Porcelain enameled stainless steel grill grates are ideal for smoking on, as they are durable and naturally non-stick and rust proof compared to normal stainless steel.
Temperature Control
When we measure the temperature control of pellet grills we look at how easy it is to adjust the temperature, the degree increments it can be set to, and how accurate it is.
Min & Max Cooking Temperature
Pellet smokers are naturally good at smoking, using pure wood-fired fuel to produce distinct smoky flavor. However, what most smokers lack is the ability to crank the heat up to sear meats. This is particularly important for reverse searing steaks for example, or to get more color on your meats.
500°F is the lowest you would want to go for searing your meats, so we will be highlighting temperature ranges of each of these models.
Meat Probe
Most pellet grills come with a meat probe for providing an instant read on the internal temperatures of your meat. We’ve highlighted these, and commented on how trustworthy their reads are.
Smoke Hollow Pellet Grill Vs Traeger Pro & Ironwood
Smoke Hollow PS2415 Pellet Grill
- Easy to use LED thermostat and a digital control temperature gauge that helps you hit that smoking sweet spot
- Collects grease easily for a no mess, no nonsense experience.
- Made from strong, durable steel that holds heat time after time
- Much more affordable than a Traeger smoker
- Not the best option for larger cook-outs
- Doesn’t come with the most advanced features
- Some customers have had trouble reaching customer service
- Hard to clean the ash that collects at the bottom over time
Specification Breakdown
- Dimensions: H 50” x L 25” x W 51”
- Weight: 120 lbs
- Temperature Range: 160°F – 485°F
- Cooking Space: 440 square inches
- Temperature Control: Digital, 5°F Increments
- Pellet Hopper Capacity: 18 lbs
- Warranty: 1 year
One of the most attractive features of the Smoke Hollow Pellet Grill is that it performs close to a top quality model, but at a fraction of the price. This pellet smoker features a sleek black exterior that looks great in your backyard. It’s just as simple to use as any other, simply load it up with your favourite flavors of wood pellets, and use the digital control to set the temperature to your liking. With a decent 18 lb pellet hopper, you’ll easily get 6-8 hours of low and slow smoking without refilling it.
This smoker comes with 440 square inches of space, giving you enough room for up to four whole chickens, four rib racks, or twenty burger patties. You’ll have enough room to cook dinner for your whole family. The Smoke Hollow Pellet Grill is a standard medium size smoker, perfect for neighborhood parties and backyard get-togethers. You could also smoke a large quantity of meat at once, then throw it in the freezer and enjoy it at a later date.
To help you maintain a consistent temperature, the Smoke Hollow Pellet Grill offers an LED thermostat and an easy-to-read temperature gauge. You’ll be able to monitor and adjust the temperature so your meat don’t get overcooked. When you’re done cooking, you can easily dispose of the grease that the grill collects in the grease pan. The grill grates are coated with porcelain, making it easy to clean and dry off. It comes on a solidly framed cart that makes it easy to move it back under cover, in a shed, or in the garage.
Overall, This pellet smoker is a good investment for anyone who loves the unique, juicy flavor of home-smoked meats. It’s not the top grill on the market, but it’s a good choice for anyone who’s looking for something a little more economical, but still wanting the power and flavor of a wood pellet smoker. You’ll get all the basic features without spending thousands of dollars.
Traeger Pro 575 Pellet Grill
- Comes with multiple settings for roasting, grilling, baking, braising and more
- Easy to use advanced WiFi technology to keep you connected to your grill, helping you adjust the temperature from anywhere around the house
- Offers a spacious grill area, approaching on the larger side of things.
- Holds up to eighteen pounds of wood pellets
- Well insulated and heavy-duty cast iron body
- Connects directly to Alexa devices
- One of the more expensive grills on the market
- Some customers have had issues with the temperature settings
- Heavy and more difficult to transport and wheel around
Specification Breakdown
- Dimensions: H 40” x L 26” x W 53”
- Weight: 124 lbs
- Temperature Range: 165°F – 500°F
- Cooking Space: 575 square inches
- Temperature Control: WiFi, 10°F Increments
- Pellet Hopper Capacity: 18 lbs
- Warranty: 3 years
The Traeger Pro 575 Grill is still at a reasonable price, but a little higher than average pellet smokers. However, some would argue that it’s well worth the extra cost. The Traeger Pro 575 offers an extra-large cooking space, advanced WiFi features and multiple grilling options that allow you to cook an entire feast. With this grill, you can roast, bake, smoke, grill and braise a wide variety of foods on your back porch.
It even comes with 2 high quality and accurate meat probes so you can track your internal tempeartures on a brisket and a pork butt at the same time! You’re not just limited to meat, either–there’s enough room to throw some vegetables on the grill along side the main course!
The Traeger Pro 575 has enough space for four chickens, five racks of ribs and twenty-four burgers. You could even throw a pizza on the grill to capture that wood-fired taste. If you’re cooking for a lot of people, this grill can handle up to eighteen pounds of wood pellets–enough to cook dinner for everybody. Plus, this grill reaches temperatures of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, enabling you to sear your meat, unlike the models that only extend to 450°F.
If you’re like most people, you probably get tired of standing at the grill for hours. When you throw a party, you want to walk around and socialize with your guests. That’s why the Traeger Pro 575 comes with an exclusive WiFi app that connects directly to your grill. You can use the app to check the temperature, set a timer and see if you need to add more pellets. For once, you can relax and enjoy yourself without having to run back to the grill every hour. It took me only a day to get used to it, its really easy to set-up and use, no mucking around.
Most people use their Traeger Pro 575 Grill for smoking meat. However, this grill has options for grilling, baking, roasting, barbecuing and more. You can barbecue hamburgers, roast vegetables and even bake a pumpkin pie on this grill. Plus, you can experiment with different types of wood pellets that infuse your meat with that classic smoky flavor. Forget about hanging out in the kitchen all day–you can use the grill and enjoy the great outdoors.
Traeger Ironwood 665 Pellet Grill
Higher Maximum Temperature
Larger Cooking Area
Super Smoke Mode
Slightly Bigger Pellet Hopper
Specification Breakdown
- Dimensions: H 46” x L 27” x W 47”
- Weight: 149 lbs
- Temperature Range: 160°F – 500°F
- Cooking Space: 650 square inches
- Temperature Control: WiFi, 10° Increments
- Pellet Hopper Capacity: 20 lbs
- Warranty: 3 years
The Trager Ironwood provides everything that the Pro series does, just on another level. Is it necessary? Well it depends on your budget and how much you value the extra features it has packed into it.
Really, Ironwood is at the top of the performance ladder, being able to reach both searing temperatures of 500°F, but also able to excel at low and slow smoking, with it’s super smoke mode releasing maximum smoke at between 165-225°F hitting that sweet spot for any low and slow journey.
Like you would expect it would, it also comes with a huge 650 square inches of cooking space, but if you often cook for the neighbourhood or a large number of guests you can extend up to the 885 square inch model. It is signifantly heavier than the Smoke Hollow Pellet Grill, but you don’t need portability then this really doesn’t matter.
If you are looking for something more lightweight, check out the best portable pellet grills.
Other Questions
Traeger Wood Pellets vs. Smoke Hollow Pellets
Wood pellets are literally the fuel for your barbecue, and you don’t want to compromise on quality as this is going to directly impact the flavor of your feast.
Traeger Grill wood pellets are arguably one of the highest quality natural hardwood wood pellets in the market. The flavor and burn consistency are top of the line, and come in a variety of smoking wood flavors, so you can really nail the smoky flavor no matter what you’re smoking.
Smoke Hollow Pellets burn nicely and incorporate a bit of bark for extra flavor. However, they do tend to burn up more quickly, are harder to source, and less popular than Traeger. They are less expensive and are certainly better than some others, which does still make them a great choice overall, but not ground-breaking.
For a full comparison, see our guide on the best wood pellets for smoking.
Is Smoke Hollow A Good Brand?
Smoke Hollow is an excelling brand and was acquired by the one and only Masterbuilt, who are world known for smokers such as the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker, or other high quality vertical electric and gas smokers. Now, with the addition of Smoke Hollow pellet grills to their repertoire, Masterbuilt/Smoke Hollow is certainly a widely trusted, quality brand.
Who Makes Smoke Hollow Grills?
Smoke Hollow pellet grills used to be produced by Outdoor Leisure Products, Inc, until they got acquired by Masterbuilt, a well established and world renowned brand. Smoke Hollow Pellet Grills are still produced under this company, but ultimately it is owned by Masterbuilt.
